Dupe Alert? Maybelline Master Precise Liquid Liner VS Kat Von D Tattoo Liquid Liner

I’ve got another Dupe Alert for you today! Today two liquid eyeliners are battling it out to see which is best: Maybelline Master Precise Liquid Liner VS Kat Von D Tattoo Liquid Liner. Let’s dive right in!

First up, let’s chat about the Kat Von D Tattoo Liquid Liner. The Tattoo eyeliner is well known in the beauty world for being one of the best, truly waterproof liquid liners on the market. Does it stand up to the claims?

Before I started using the Kat Von D liner, I was using Lorac Front of the Line Pro. I loved everything about Front of the Line Pro – it applies so easily, the tip is flexible but stiff, and it is so easy to make cat eye lines with this liner. But my main complaint was that the line faded throughout the day. It would start off black but fade to grey by the end of the day. Also, if my eyes watered, the line would gradually disappear at the corners of my eyes. I had always just dealt with the drawbacks, but one day I watched an Instastory of my friend Tricia (the makeup artist). She was raving about Kat Von D Tattoo Liquid Eyeliner, so I decided to pick one up about a year and a half ago. I’ve repurchased twice since then.

Before I review, let me first state that I have extremely oily eyelids. I use a primer each day before I apply my eyeshadow, but naturally my lids are just oily. I also have allergies and wear contacts, so my eyes water and I rub them a lot. In addition, I have hooded eyelids, so it’s pretty common for me to experience eyeliner transfer to my crease.

Buy It Here

I’ve been really happy with the Kat Von D Liquid Eyeliner. The felt tip is very stiff, which is both a good and bad thing. I prefer the tip of the Front of the Line Pro, because I think a little flexibility is good when creating a cat eye. But the positive about the stiff tip of the Tattoo liner is that you can create very crisp lines. It is truly 100% waterproof. It lasts all day. It doesn’t transfer to my crease or smudge once it is set. The other thing I truly love about this liner is that is a carbon black – and it stays that black all day long.

One negative is that it can tend to feather as you apply – meaning, as you trace the liner onto your lid, if you don’t hold the liner a very specific way, the line blurs slightly.

Pros:

  • It really is waterproof.
  • The color doesn’t fade throughout the day.
  • The felt tip makes it easy to draw crisp lines.
  • The color does not smudge or transfer once it fully dries.

Cons:

  • You can experience feathering as you draw your line.
  • The felt tip is very stiff – which in my opinion can sometimes make it difficult to apply.
  • At $20, it is more expensive than the Maybelline version.
  • It is only available at Sephora and online retailers.

Amazon / Ulta

Next up we have the Maybelline Master Precise Liquid Eyeliner. I really, really, really want to love this product. I DO love this product. I just love it knowing it isn’t perfect.

First up, the price: it is $5.49 on Amazon and $8.49 at Ulta. It’s a fourth of the price of the Kat Von D liner! This makes it much more appealing to me.

Application: I actually really prefer the tip of the Maybelline liner over the Kat Von D liner. It is felt tip, but the tip is longer. The base is stiff, but the tip is more flexible, meaning it’s just easier to get in and create those angles and curves. It comes out very wet, but it dries quickly. I find myself having to create a “surprise” face when I’m using this liner so that it can dry without transferring of smudging. The best part: the black is truly black. It doesn’t fade throughout the day.

HOWEVER, [crying emoji] it transfers.

I feel like I’ve tried this every which way to Sunday. The first time I wore it, I did not wear eye primer. Hmm, I thought, maybe that’s why it transferred. The next time I wore it, I set the liner with a bit of black eyeshadow. Nope, still smudged. In the picture you see above, I’m wearing eye primer, and still experienced transfer to the crease.

With that said, it isn’t like the smudging or transfer is impossible to work with. I know I sound wishy washy, but if you just need an affordable, easy to use liquid eyeliner this is for you. You will likely have to clean up some smudges, so make sure you stash a q-tip in your purse. They are easy to clean up with your fingertip or some light blending. But be prepared – it will happen.

Pros:

  • Affordable: using a coupon or store sale, you can likely score this for around $5.
  • It’s widely available online and in stores such as Walmart, Ulta, Target, and drugstores.
  • The color is very black, and it does not fade throughout the day.
  • I really enjoy the packaging! It’s nice and sleek. It doesn’t look cheap at all.
  • Has a stiff yet flexible tip that allows you to create crisp lines and angles

Cons:

  • It smudges.
  • It isn’t waterproof. Crying or watery eyes will cause the line to run or disappear.
  • It transfers to your crease throughout the day.
  • This is a tiny thing: when you shake the Kat Von D eyeliner, it makes noise. The Maybelline does not. I find something about the clacking sound of the Tattoo liner to be so reassuring!

Final verdict: although there are many things I DO love about the Maybelline Master Precise Liquid Eyeliner, I do not love that it requires tending throughout the day. With the Kat Von D, I can apply in the morning and know it will still look the same when I take it off 12 hours later. For that reason, I recommend purchasing the Kat Von D Tattoo Liner over the Maybelline Master Precise Liquid Liner.

Comments

  1. Literally NEEDED liquid eyeliner like today – you are so timely….running out to get the Kat Von D, but love that Maybelline has an option if I’m in a bind to locate a replacement. Thank you!

Speak Your Mind

*